Financial Foreplay
How the Rich Seduce Banks Into Making Them Wealthier
Listen to a podcast-style discussion of this article or download it here
The Tale of Two Brothers
In a small coastal town, two brothers inherited equal shares of their father's modest fishing business. Each received $50,000 and a simple boat.
The elder brother, Marcus, had watched their father struggle with debt his whole life—the credit cards, the payday loans, the constant stress of bills. He vowed never to borrow a cent. He saved diligently, paid cash for everything, and slept soundly knowing he owed no one.
The younger brother, David, noticed something different. He saw how the wealthy marina owner had borrowed to build the docks where they moored. How the successful restaurant chain downtown had started with a business loan. How property developers leveraged mortgages to build empires.
Marcus saved for five years to buy a second boat outright. David borrowed $200,000 that same month, bought four boats, and hired crews to run them. The interest payments made Marcus's stomach churn just hearing about them.
Ten years later, Marcus owned two boats free and clear, worth $100,000 total. He was debt-free and proud.
David owned a fleet of twelve boats and the marina where they docked. He owed the bank $800,000 and was worth $3 million.
Both brothers were right about debt. And both were wrong.
The Psychology of Our Debt Phobia
Ask most people about debt, and watch their shoulders tense. It's a visceral reaction, bred from generations of wisdom about the dangers of owing money. And for good reason—consumer debt can be a ruthless destroyer of wealth and wellbeing.
We've all heard the horror stories. The credit card that started at $1,000 and ballooned to $10,000. The payday loan trap. The home equity line that funded a lifestyle until it didn't. These cautionary tales shape our relationship with debt from an early age.
This fear isn't irrational. It's protective. Like teaching children to fear fire, warning against debt keeps people from financial burns. The problem arises when we can't distinguish between a destructive wildfire and the controlled flame that heats our home.
The problem is that this visceral aversion to ‘debt’ is the equivalent of a heuristic—a rule of thumb the works well enough often enough. But there are exceptions…
Understanding the Debt Spectrum
Here's what's rarely discussed in personal finance circles: debt exists on a spectrum, and where it falls depends entirely on what it's used for.
The debt spectrum ranges from financially destructive to wealth-building, and understanding where different types fall can transform your financial decision-making. At the toxic end, we have what I call "vampire debt"—high-interest credit cards charging 20-25% annually, payday loans that can effectively cost 400% per year, and cash advances that drain your financial lifeblood faster than you can replenish it. This debt is mathematically impossible to justify; you're essentially paying $1.25 or more for every dollar you borrow within a year. It's the financial equivalent of trying to fill a bucket with a massive hole in the bottom.
Moving along the spectrum, we find "vanity debt"—borrowing for things that lose value while stroking our ego. The classic example is the luxury car loan, where you're paying interest on an asset depreciating at 15-20% annually. You're not just losing the car's value; you're paying extra for the privilege. Similarly, borrowing for an expensive wedding, designer goods, or lifestyle upgrades falls here. It's not quite as mathematically punishing as vampire debt, but it's still making you systematically poorer. Then there's what I call "survival debt"—not ideal, but sometimes necessary. This includes borrowing to cover rent during a rough patch, a business line of credit to manage cash flow gaps, or a loan to handle emergency medical expenses. While not wealth-building, this debt serves a purpose: keeping you afloat so you can fight another day.
At the positive end of the spectrum lies "productive debt"—borrowing that puts money in your pocket. The rental property where tenants pay your mortgage plus provide cash flow. The business loan for equipment that doubles your production capacity. The strategic mortgage on a home in a growing area where appreciation outpaces interest costs. Even carefully chosen student debt can fit here if it genuinely increases earning power (though this is increasingly debatable). The key distinction? Good debt buys assets that generate income or appreciate faster than the interest rate you're paying. It's using the bank's money to build your wealth, with built-in mechanisms to pay for itself. The wealthy understand this distinction intimately—they borrow at 5% to invest in opportunities yielding 10%, 15%, or more, essentially getting paid to use other people's money.
Most financial advice lumps all debt together, creating a black-and-white worldview that serves no one well. It's like saying all mushrooms are poisonous because some can kill you—technically safer, but you miss out on a lot of truffle risotto.
Why the Wealthy Think Differently About Debt
Sarah, a property investor in Sydney, shared a perspective that would make many people uncomfortable: "I'm $2.3 million in debt and it's the best financial decision I've made."
Ten years ago, she bought her first investment property with a $400,000 mortgage. The rental income covered the payments, and she used the equity growth to borrow for a second property. Then a third. Today, she owns five properties worth $3.5 million collectively. After debt, her net worth is $1.2 million.
"My friends who saved every penny and bought one house outright are worth maybe $800,000," she explains. "They played it safe, and there's nothing wrong with that. But they worked for every dollar of their wealth. My tenants and time built most of mine."
This isn't unique to property. Business owners routinely use debt to scale operations. James started his electrical contracting business with a $50,000 equipment loan. "I could have saved for two years to buy that equipment," he says. "Instead, I borrowed, started earning immediately, and paid off the loan in eight months from the additional income it generated."
The Mathematics of Good Debt
The concept is surprisingly simple, though our emotions often cloud the logic. If you can borrow at 5% to invest in something returning 10%, you're making 5% on money that isn't even yours.
This is called leverage, and it's the not-so-secret weapon of wealth creation.
Consider two scenarios:
Scenario A: You have $100,000 saved. You buy one rental property outright. It appreciates 7% annually and provides $20,000 yearly rental income. After 10 years, you have a property worth $196,715 plus $200,000 in collected rent (simplified, ignoring costs). Total: roughly $400,000.
Scenario B: You use that same $100,000 as deposits on four $500,000 properties (20% down each). You owe $1.6 million at 5% interest. The properties appreciate at the same 7% annually. After 10 years, your properties are worth $3.9 million. Even after paying off significant mortgage principal and interest, you're typically ahead by over $1 million compared to Scenario A.
The difference? Leverage. And courage.
The Psychological Barriers We Face
Understanding the math is one thing. Overcoming our psychological barriers is another entirely.
Dr. Daniel Kahneman's research on loss aversion shows we feel losses twice as powerfully as equivalent gains. This makes debt feel doubly dangerous—we focus on the monthly payments (loss) more than the wealth being built (gain).
There's also what psychologists call "temporal discounting"—we overvalue immediate costs and undervalue future benefits. That mortgage payment is due next month (immediate, concrete, painful). The equity growth and rental income compound over years (distant, abstract, uncertain).
Add social conditioning to the mix. How many times have you heard "debt-free" spoken with the reverence usually reserved for "cancer-free"? We've created a culture where all debt is viewed as a disease, rather than recognizing that some debt is more like a powerful medicine—helpful in the right doses for the right conditions.
The Critical Distinction Most People Miss
Here's what separates good debt from bad, and why most people struggle with the concept: good debt pays for itself.
When Marcus from our opening story thinks about debt, he imagines writing checks every month—money flowing out, stress flowing in. When David thinks about debt, he sees his fishing crews generating income that covers the loan payments and then some.
A mortgage on your home? That's neutral debt—it doesn't generate income, but it fixes your housing costs and historically appreciates. Not great, not terrible.
A mortgage on a rental property where tenants pay rent exceeding your costs? That's good debt. You're essentially using the bank's money to build wealth, with someone else paying it off.
A business loan that lets you fulfill more orders, serve more customers, or improve efficiency? Good debt, assuming you've done your homework.
Credit cards for consumer goods? Bad debt, almost always. The items you buy lose value while you pay interest on the privilege of early ownership.
Real-World Success Stories (And Cautionary Tales)
Tom, a Melbourne-based entrepreneur, built a multi-million dollar consulting firm using strategic debt. "Every time we needed to hire before we had the cash flow, we borrowed," he explains. "Each new consultant generated three times their cost in revenue. The math was clear, even if the monthly payments were scary."
But he's quick to add warnings: "I've also seen people destroy themselves trying to replicate this without understanding the fundamentals. They borrow for things that seem like investments but aren't—fancy offices, unnecessary equipment, speculative ventures."
This brings us to a crucial point: good debt requires good judgment. It's not about borrowing indiscriminately and hoping for the best. It's about careful analysis, realistic projections, and yes, accepting calculated risks.
The Framework for Thinking About Debt
If you're wrestling with whether debt might serve your wealth-building goals, consider these questions:
Will this debt pay for itself? If you need to work harder to make the payments, it's probably bad debt. If the asset generates income covering the payments, you're on the right track.
What's your margin of safety? Good debt assumes things go reasonably well, not perfectly. Can you handle interest rate rises? Vacancy periods? Economic downturns?
Are you borrowing for an appreciating asset? This isn't foolproof—assets can decline—but historically, quality real estate and profitable businesses increase in value over time.
Do you understand what you're investing in? Borrowing to invest in something you don't understand is gambling with leverage. Never a good idea.
What's your exit strategy? Good debt comes with a plan. How will you eventually pay it off or sell the asset?
Overcoming the Emotional Hurdles
If you've been raised to fear debt, considering it as a tool feels like learning to breathe underwater—unnatural and terrifying. Here's what helps:
Start small: You don't need to borrow millions. Many successful property investors started with one modest rental. Business owners often begin with small equipment loans.
Education before action: Read books by people who've successfully used leverage. "Rich Dad Poor Dad" by Robert Kiyosaki, despite its flaws, opened many minds to thinking differently about debt.
Find mentors: Talk to people who've built wealth using good debt. Their lived experience can help normalize what feels foreign.
Run the numbers repeatedly: Spreadsheets don't feel fear. When emotion clouds judgment, return to the mathematics.
Accept the discomfort: Using leverage responsibly often means living with some level of debt for years or decades. This discomfort is the price of accelerated wealth building.
The Warnings That Must Be Said
Before anyone rushes out to borrow, let's be crystal clear about the risks. Leverage amplifies gains, but it equally amplifies losses. If you borrow to buy assets that decline in value or fail to generate expected income, you can end up worse than broke—you can end up broke and owing money.
The property investors of 2007 learned this painfully. The business owners who borrowed heavily just before COVID-19 faced existential challenges. Debt adds risk, always.
This is why the wealthy who use debt successfully typically follow strict principles:
Never borrow more than you can afford to lose
Maintain emergency reserves
Diversify your risks
Understand your investments deeply
Be prepared to weather downturns
Good debt isn't about being reckless. It's about being strategic.
The Path Forward
The brothers from our opening tale represent two valid approaches to wealth building. Marcus, the saver, achieved financial security through discipline and patience. His path is admirable and right for many people. If debt keeps you awake at night, no investment return is worth your peace of mind.
David, the borrower, achieved greater wealth by accepting calculated risks and using other people's money to accelerate his progress. His path requires more sophistication and comfort with uncertainty, but the rewards can be substantial.
Neither path is inherently right or wrong. The tragedy is when people capable of David's approach limit themselves to Marcus's path out of unexamined fear, or when natural Marcus types force themselves into David's strategy and suffer the stress.
Your Relationship With Debt
Perhaps it's time to examine your own beliefs about debt. Where did they come from? Are they serving you? Are they based on understanding or fear?
You might discover, as many do, that your aversion to all debt is costing you opportunities. Or you might confirm that a debt-free life aligns with your values and temperament. Both conclusions are valid.
What matters is making the choice consciously, understanding that debt—like fire, like water, like most powerful tools—isn't inherently good or evil. It's a force that can build or destroy, depending entirely on how it's wielded.
The wealthy understand this. They've learned to dance with debt rather than flee from it. They've mastered the paradox that borrowing money can make you richer, that owing can lead to owning, that strategic vulnerability can create strength.
Whether you choose to join them is up to you. But at least now you know the dance exists.