Broke Is a Season, Not Your Name
How one money story can keep you stuck long after the number changes
Listen to a podcast-style discussion of this article or download it here
Subscribe for free to receive new posts and get my mini-Ebook Master Your Mindset
There’s a river in the dry country that disappears every year.
For a few months it’s just a winding scar in the dirt. Cracked mud, bleached stones, the odd skeleton of a fish that didn’t read the weather. If you wandered up to it for the first time in that season, you’d swear nothing had ever lived there. You’d call it a dead riverbed and you’d move on, and nobody could blame you for the mistake.
But the animals that live along it know better. The kangaroos still pad down to the bend where the water used to be. The birds still nest in the river gums. They’re not being sentimental. They know something a stranger doesn’t. The river isn’t dead. It’s just having its dry season. The water has gone underground, or upstream, or into the sky for a while, and it is coming back. It always comes back.
The riverbed and the dead riverbed look identical for a few months. One holds its breath. The other has stopped breathing. The trick, if you live there, is knowing which one you’re standing in.
I think a lot of us get this wrong about money. And I think the mistake costs us far more than the dry season ever does.
Two words we use as if they’re the same
Broke and poor.
We throw them around like synonyms. “I’m so broke.” “I’m so poor.” Same shrug, same empty wallet, same Tuesday.
But sit with them for a second and they start to feel different.
Broke is something that’s happening to you right now. The rent went up, the car needed a new clutch, the hours got cut, the month had too many days in it. Broke is a number. The number is low. Sometimes it’s below zero. It’s uncomfortable and it’s real, and it is also, almost always, a thing that has a before and an after.
Poor is different. When we say poor, we’re usually not talking about this month’s number. We’re talking about who we are. Poor isn’t “I have no money right now.” Poor is “I’m a person who has no money.” One is a weather report. The other is a description of the climate. One is a season. The other is a place you’ve decided you live.
That slip, from “this is happening” to “this is who I am”, is the whole ballgame. And I want to spend the rest of this piece on it, because I think it’s one of the most expensive things our minds do to us.
The story we tell on top of the number
Here’s the thing about being broke.
The number doesn’t actually say anything about you. It’s just a number. What we do, being the meaning-hungry creatures we are, is build a story on top of it.
Call it the poverty story.
It’s the narrative you wrap around the empty account. And the story is almost never just “my balance is low.” It’s bigger and darker than that. It sounds like:
“I’m bad with money.”
“People like me don’t get ahead.”
“This is just how it’s always going to be.”
“I’m just not the kind of person who has savings.”
Notice that none of those are facts about your bank account. They’re facts about your identity, or at least they’re claims about it.
The number is temporary. The story, once you’ve told it to yourself enough times, starts to feel permanent.
And the most important thing about the poverty story is that it doesn’t just describe your situation.
It starts to shape it.
Why the story is the dangerous part
Psychologists have a tidy phrase for what happens next.
The self-fulfilling prophecy.
It’s the idea that a belief about yourself can reach out and make itself come true, not by magic, but by changing what you do.
It works like this.
If you believe, deep down, that you’re just a poor person and that’s that, then a whole set of actions stops making sense.
Why bother putting twenty dollars aside? Twenty dollars won’t fix a life.
Why read the thing about the savings account, or ask about the better deal, or picture next year being any different?
People like you don’t get ahead, remember. So you don’t do the small things. And because you don’t do the small things, next year really does look like this year. Which proves the story right. Which makes you tell it harder.
The belief didn’t predict the future. It built it.
And here’s the cruel little twist.
The story feels like realism. It feels like you’re just being honest with yourself, not getting your hopes up, not being naive. It dresses up as wisdom.
But it’s not describing reality. It’s manufacturing it, one skipped action at a time.
This is why I’d argue that internalising “I’m poor” can do more damage than the broke season itself. The dry spell passes on its own eventually. The story doesn’t. The story can outlive every single circumstance that started it.
People claw their way to real financial breathing room and still feel poor, still flinch at every purchase, still narrate their life as a poor person’s life, because the number changed and the story never got the memo.
What you actually get to change
Now, I want to be careful here, because there’s a lazy version of this argument that I have no time for.
The lazy version says poverty is all in your head. Just think positive and the money appears. That’s nonsense, and worse, it’s the kind of nonsense that blames people for their own hard luck.
If your hours got cut, that’s not a mindset problem.
If the rent is genuinely more than your pay, no amount of reframing pays the gap.
Some dry seasons are long and brutal and have absolutely nothing to do with how you think about them.
Reframing the river does not make it rain.
I won’t pretend otherwise, and you should be suspicious of anyone who does.
So let me be precise about what the mindset actually changes, because it isn’t the number.
What it changes is the story you build on the number. And the story matters because the story decides what you bother trying next.
“I’m broke right now” keeps you in the driver’s seat. It’s a problem you’re moving through, so you stay alert to the exits: the better deal, the spare twenty, the small move that compounds.
“I am poor” takes your hands off the wheel. If that’s just who you are, there are no exits to look for. Why would you look for the way out of a place you live?
You can’t always control the season. You can almost always control whether you decide it’s permanent. And that one decision, made over and over in tiny moments, is the difference between a riverbed and a dead riverbed.
How to keep the broke season from becoming the poverty story
Simply identifying the issue has very limited value.
I don’t want to stop at the part where I’ve named the problem, because that’s where most of this kind of writing quits, right when it gets useful.
So here are a few things that actually help, not because they’re clever, but because they put a wedge between the number and the story.
Watch your verbs
This sounds small. It isn’t.
“I’m broke this month” and “I’m a poor person” describe the same wallet and two completely different lives.
Catch yourself when the temporary thing, “I have no money right now”, tries to harden into the permanent thing, “I’m just poor.”
The first is a weather report. Speak it like one.
Words matter. They make a big difference, probably a bigger difference than most of us realise. The way you speak to yourself is incredibly important.
Put a fence around the season
A dry spell has edges. Try to find them.
Is this a bad month, a bad few months, a stretch until a known thing changes?
Even a rough, hopeful guess at where the season ends keeps it from spreading to fill your whole self-image.
Do one small thing the “poor person” wouldn’t bother with
Set aside five dollars.
Ask the question.
Look at the number instead of hiding from it.
The point isn’t that five dollars fixes anything. The point is that the action contradicts the story, and the story can’t survive too much contradiction.
Separate the maths from the meaning
The maths is real and it deserves a clear head: what’s coming in, what’s going out, what’s actually true this month.
But the meaning, the part where the low number gets translated into “this is who I am”, is optional.
You’re allowed to look at a hard number and refuse to turn it into a verdict on your worth.
None of this is a magic trick, and I’m not promising the season ends faster because you renamed it. Sometimes it’s just long.
But there’s a real difference between waiting out a dry season and moving into a dead riverbed for good, and the difference is almost entirely the story you tell while you wait.
Back to the river
The animals along that river never confuse the two.
They’ve seen the water leave and come back too many times to fall for the cracked mud. They don’t pack up and declare the place dead the first dry month. They know the difference between a river that’s resting and a river that’s gone, and they live their lives accordingly, padding down to the bend, waiting, trusting the season to turn.
Broke is the dry season.
It’s real, it’s uncomfortable, and there’s nothing shameful about standing in it. Plenty of good people, working hard, doing everything right, are standing in it this very minute through no fault of their own.
Poor, the way we usually mean it, is something else.
It’s deciding the river is dead. It’s writing the season into your name.
The water is underground more often than you’d think. The trick is not to bury the river while it’s only resting.
Check out the Financology podcast on Spotify
or iTunes