Avoid This Financial Scam
Buy Now, Pain Later
Listen to a podcast-style discussion of this article or download it here
The 3am Shopping Spree That Spiralled Into $25,000 of Debt
Jessica couldn't sleep. At 3am, bathed in the blue light of her phone, she was scrolling through Instagram when she saw it – the perfect kitchen stand mixer. The one all the food influencers used. The one she'd been eyeing for months.
$499. Way more than she could afford right now.
But then those magical words appeared: "Pay only $124.75 today with Afterpay."
Four easy payments. No interest. No credit check.
"It's practically free money," she thought, her finger hovering over the button.
Six months later, Jessica sat surrounded by unopened packages – clothing, makeup, home decor, electronics – all purchased through various Buy Now Pay Later services. Her bank account was overdrawn. Multiple payment deadlines had been missed. Late fees were piling up. And that stand mixer? Still in its box, unused.
Jessica had fallen into the $25,000 debt trap that started with the gateway drug of 4 seemingly innocent payments of $124.75.
The Buy Now Pay Later Revolution (And Why Your Brain Loves It)
Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL) services have exploded in popularity. Afterpay, Klarna, Affirm, and others have transformed how we shop online. The concept seems simple: split your purchase into smaller instalments, usually interest-free.
What could go wrong?
As it turns out, plenty. And it's not just about poor financial planning – it's about how your brain is wired to make decisions.
Your Brain on BNPL: The Psychology Behind the Purchase
Present Bias: Why Today's Joy Trumps Tomorrow's Pain
Imagine I offer you $100 today or $120 in a month. Which would you choose?
Many people would grab the $100 right now, even though waiting means getting more money. This is "present bias" – our tendency to value immediate rewards far more than future benefits.
BNPL services exploit this brilliantly. They offer immediate gratification (getting your purchase now) while pushing the pain of payment into the future.
People are very good at understanding “immediate rewards”, but not so good at understanding “eventual pain”.
Think about it like this: When you're at the checkout and see that $200 coat you want, your brain experiences two competing forces:
1. The pleasure of getting the coat
2. The pain of spending $200
But when BNPL splits it into four $50 payments with the first due today, something changes. The full pain of $200 becomes distant and fuzzy, while the pleasure remains immediate and vivid. Your brain thinks: "$50? That's nothing compared to how good I'll feel wearing this coat!"
This happens even if you logically know you'll still be paying the full $200. The psychological impact of splitting payments takes advantage of how your brain naturally discounts future events.
The Coffee Cup Example
Consider your morning coffee habit. A $5 latte seems like nothing today. But that same $5 daily for a year is $1,825 – which suddenly feels like a lot of money!
If I asked you, "Would you spend $1,825 on coffee this year?" you might hesitate. But asking "Would you spend $5 on coffee today?" feels like an easy yes. Same money, different framing.
BNPL kind of works the same way – turning big, scary prices into small, harmless-seeming payments.
Loss Aversion: Why Losing Hurts More Than Winning Feels Good
Here's a quick experiment: I'll flip a coin. If it's heads, I give you $100. If it's tails, you give me $100. Would you take that bet?
Most people wouldn't – even though mathematically, it's a fair bet with an expected value of zero. Why? Because humans typically feel the pain of losing $100 about twice as strongly as the pleasure of gaining $100. This is loss aversion.
BNPL flips loss aversion on its head. When you're shopping traditionally, you experience the loss (paying money) and the gain (getting the item) at the same time. The loss can sometimes overpower the joy of the purchase.
But with BNPL, you get the full joy of acquiring the item immediately, while the loss is minimized to just that first small payment. The rest of the payments – the majority of the loss – are pushed into the future.
The Candy Bar Now vs. Health Later Example
Imagine you're on a diet, but someone offers you a delicious chocolate bar. Your brain faces a classic conflict:
· Immediate reward: The taste and pleasure of chocolate right now
· Delayed consequence: Slightly worse health and guilt later
When the reward is immediate but the consequence is delayed, our present-biased brains often choose immediate gratification. This is exactly how BNPL works with your money – all pleasure now, pain later.
The Hidden Dangers Behind Those 4 Easy Payments
While BNPL services advertise transparency and simplicity, the reality is often more complicated:
1. The Stack-Up Effect: Multiple small payments from different purchases all coming due around the same time can create an unexpected financial burden.
2. The Spending Increase: Studies show people spend 20-40% more when using BNPL services compared to traditional payment methods. Using BNPL can be a slippery slope
3. The Late Fee Trap: Miss a payment and you could face substantial fees, sometimes 25% of the purchase price.
4. The Credit Score Impact: Some BNPL services report late payments to credit bureaus, affecting your credit score.
How to Use BNPL Wisely (If You Must)
Despite the psychological traps, BNPL can be a useful tool when used strategically:
· The 24-Hour Rule: Add items to your cart, but wait 24 hours before completing the purchase. This helps combat impulse buying.
· The Budget-First Approach: Before using BNPL, add all future payments to your budget for the upcoming months to ensure you can actually afford them.
· The One-at-a-Time Method: Never have more than one BNPL agreement active at once. Complete all payments before starting a new one.
· The Emergency-Only Strategy: Reserve BNPL for genuine needs, not wants.
It all basically comes down to exercising restraint.
The Liberation of Delayed Gratification
Perhaps the most powerful tool against BNPL pitfalls is embracing delayed gratification – saving for what you want rather than splitting payments.
Sarah, a reformed BNPL addict, shared: "I now put the 'four easy payments' amount into a separate savings account each week. After a few weeks, I can buy the item outright – or I often realize I didn't want it that badly after all. It's liberating to own things fully from the start rather than having payments hanging over me."
Breaking the Cycle
BNPL services aren't inherently evil. They're tools that can be useful in certain situations. But they're designed to take advantage of psychological biases we all share.
By understanding how your brain responds to these payment options, you gain power over your decisions. You can step back and ask: "Do I want this because I truly need it, or because the payment structure makes it feel falsely affordable?"
Remember Jessica from our opening story? After hitting rock bottom with her BNPL debt, she deleted all shopping apps, removed saved payment information, and started a strict debt repayment plan. Six months later, she had paid off $10,000 and now saves for purchases instead of splitting payments.
"The stand mixer that started it all? I eventually sold it unused," she says. "The money went toward paying off the debt it helped create. The irony isn't lost on me."
Next time those magical words "Pay in 4 interest-free instalments" appear on your screen, remember: your brain is being hacked. The question isn't whether you can afford the first payment – it's whether this purchase aligns with your long-term financial wellbeing.
Because financial freedom feels better than any purchase ever could – and that's not something you can buy now and pay for later.